Kommody

Crop-weighted weather: why national averages mislead

Crop-weighted weather is rainfall and temperature averaged over the land where a crop is actually grown, with each area weighted by how much of the crop it produces. It answers the question a commodity analyst cares about, how the weather is for the crop, instead of how the weather is for the country as a whole.

By the Kommody team · Updated

Why national averages mislead

Brazil's average rainfall is dominated by the Amazon, where almost no soybeans grow. A dry week in Mato Grosso can be invisible in a national number and decisive for the crop. Weighting by crop area fixes that, and also lets the same country have a different weather signal for each crop.

How it is built

Start with gridded weather: a reanalysis such as ERA5 from the Copernicus Climate Change Service for history, and a forecast model such as ECMWF's IFS for recent days and the coming two weeks. Overlay a map of harvested area for each crop, weight each grid cell by its area, and aggregate to regions and countries.

Comparing with the same calendar days over the last 5 or 10 years turns raw values into anomalies, which is what moves markets. Expressing anomalies in standard deviations makes regions with very different climates comparable.

Reading it well

A few habits help:

  • Look at accumulated rain over 10 to 30 days, not single days
  • Focus on the crop's sensitive stage: pollination, pod filling, flowering
  • Check the forecast against observed data as it rolls in
  • Filter out regions where the crop is marginal so they do not dilute the signal

Frequently asked questions

What is ERA5?
ERA5 is the fifth-generation global climate reanalysis from ECMWF, produced by the Copernicus Climate Change Service. It provides hourly weather from 1940 onwards on a consistent grid.
How far ahead are weather forecasts useful for crops?
Deterministic and ensemble forecasts are most reliable for about 10 to 15 days; beyond that, seasonal outlooks give probabilities rather than specific values.

Related

See it with live data in Kommody

Weather, news, positioning and prediction markets for the commodities you follow, in one dashboard or in your AI assistant.